Every plot element that was removed from the theatrical adaptation of Ender's Game improved the final product, and it was still a dumpster fire of clumsy dialogue, uninspired science fiction tropes, bad costumes, child psychopaths, and disturbing ethical rationalizations.
There's multiple reasons that for quite a long time this novel was considered unfilmable, and they can be broken down into two categories: Effects and Plot.
The diatribe will begin with effects and physical delivery of the film, being the least objectionable and poisonous aspects derived from the epic Mormon creation from the demonhorn-tipped quill of Orson Scott Card.
Battle School in Space, which is what the location is literally actually referred to, is the main setting for our adventure. If you're at all familiar with the source material, which i unfortunately hope you would be if you're bothering to read this hot mess of rambling poorly grammartized musings, then you know about Battle School in Space. The end result of the International Space Station if the solar system was invaded by a group of insectoid aliens, and the governments of Earth allied themselves to create a United Nations that you can be elected President to by posting persuading essays in internet comment sections.
A sprawling rotating station with a big sphere in the middle where the teachers can torture the shit out of their child students, the sheer technical hurdle of depicting it without looking like an episode of the big bang theory kept the movie from being greenlit for multiple decades. And everyone still looked awkward floating around the arena, since humans look like flailing dummies in simulated low gravity, it's just in our nature.
Set design was... passable, until the act when our intrepid hero Andrew "Bender" Wiggin was sent to a captured Bugger planet to do more war stuff that wound up turning into genocide. I don't know what it is, but from Stargate SG-1 to any movie with insectioid aliens... Starship Troopers for example, they just can't properly recreate an environment an insectoid alien would live in. The floors are always flat, the doorways are always human sized. It shouldn't rustle my Jimmies but it does.
Costumes: i didn't expect to see any Adidas underwear logos but... here we are. Apparently the official clothing supplier to the International Fleet Fleet is one of Nike's competitors, and their logo hasn't changed in about 150 years.
Plot:
So it's generally agreed upon that Orson Scott Card is a pretty terrible person. At least, it's agreed upon if you're NOT a bad person with bad opinions and ideas and should not be ground up into food for the less fortunate/fertilizer/Torgo's Executive powder.
What bothers me, always has and always will, is the argument that you need to try to look past Card's obscenely regressive backwards harmful opinions and judge the work on its own merits, like the two are mutually exclusive.
They are not.
When someone who has continually expressed bad opinions, (let's just go with Hitler since it's the easiest/most unfair example), creates something, like a book, you cannot separate the person from the creation. It's like God. Or if like you had friends who told you they were really getting into the Mein Kampf series and that you should check it out.
That feeling is partially because stuff written by a bad person is always going to be tinged with their personal philosophy, and partially because Ender's Game frankly isn't that good. The series isn't.
Is it readable? In general, yes, aside from the weird Chinese stuff in the third book, but is it deserving of the #1 spot on the list of greatest science-fiction novels of all time?
Fuck no.
Fuck no.
http://www4.ncsu.edu/~tenshi/Killer_000.htm
This is a paper that puts forward pretty much my exact argument only much more eloquently and with less profanity, so it's worth a read.
What makes Ender's Game so dangerous is that it's read by people while they're children and they identify with the main character. He's small, bullied, but in the end he's better than everyone else and is a winner even if everyone doesn't realize it, since you're special. You, the reader. You and Ender are friends from the start.
Then you go back to it as an adult, and nostalgia clouds the child murder, the rationalizing of violence as both a first and last resort, and the idea that 6-15 year olds are the future of the military industrial complex.
But that's all about the book. We're talking about the movie adaptation OF the book, where most attention is paid to the detail of what has been included, and what has been excised. Like Jurassic Park, and how it took 3 movies to get to the pteranodons.
Remember all those interludes from Battle School in Space where Bender's siblings, where sociopath asshole Peter and empathetic pussy Valentine basically become the first internet superstars by arguing about how Earth needs to go to war in the comments sections of blogs?
Yeah that's gone. Thank god.
Yeah that's gone. Thank god.
Instead what we have is a pretty much uninterrupted Education of Bender Wiggin at the Space School of Hard Knocks, since as we learn early on in the film the I.F. fleet (heretofore referred to as the International Fleet Fleet) is only 26 days and some-odd hours away from the Bugger home planet. So there's a time limit, and Harrison Ford, playing a tired and angry Colonel Graff, needs to grumble his motley band of rejects and losers and murderers to victory ASAP. However...
There's never any real set of stakes in Bender's Game. The movie decides that it's 50 years after the first invasion of the homosexuals where they were defeated by Ben Kingsley flying an F-22 jet into the mothership and killing it EXACTLY like Randy Quaid in Independence Day. Almost shot for shot. So apparently the greatest tactical mind before Bender lifted his ideas directly from an excellent Roland Emmerich movie. Don't mess with Earth/welcome to it. Bender MUST complete his college education before his balls drop, and the timeframe is meaningless
Asa Butter field, aside from having a terrible name, is a... bad child actor. Most are. Eventually he'll be good looking and deep voiced and buff and girls will want to rub up against him so much he'll look like a glazed doughnut but right now he's just awkward. Hiring a british actor for an american role isn't necessarily risky, but when their accent breaks through the dialogue while you're there since they have to scream a lot, it's not necessarily the best time. And as for the rest of the cast, I have both faint and damning praise. I leaned over to Nick about halfway through the movie to whisper "I find it interesting that every woman in this movie is a huge pussy".
Bender's mom: coward.
Viola Davis: military psychologist, and coward.
Abigail Breslin/Bender's weird incestual romance sister: reinforces Bender's pre-emptive self-defense murder philosophy, also a coward though she herself is kinda a psychopath.
Petra Arkanian: only girl with speaking lines in Battle School in Space, nice to Bender on the outset thereby revealing her cowardice.
BUT I will say that i appreciated the movie having non-whites and/or men in roles that contributed to the plot. Bean and the Muslim kid (who i was amazed was allowed to have speaking lines) are both nonwhites, the one sergeant dude that teaches recruits and tells Bender he'll never salute him is Xaro Xoan Daxos from Game of Thrones.
I love when actors are not the race or gender that books make them out to be. Ursula K.LeGuin, a much better SF author than Card, goes out of her goddamn way to tell her readers that her characters are people of color, because in the cold dark dystopian universe of the future, we're all gonna look olive/mahogany skinned and sexy as hell.
[BIOLOGY ASIDE NOTE] My favorite authors don't cater to an audience. They embrace the diversity we encounter in our daily lives. Our species wouldn't exist if it wasn't for our shockingly varied phenotype and adaptive ability, and my favorite authors ranging from Richard K. Morgan to Kameron Hurley pick characters with a heritage that can be proudly referred to as multicultural. Even if they're white. 'Purity' is an illusion, I myself am a mop bucket of all your garbage genetic strains of Europe, I wish that I had something more exotic in me than a half Turkish grandfather. When I see alarmist news articles about how in 75 years america will resemble Brazil more than any other country i say bring on the slammin' booties.[END BIODIVERSITY DIATRIBE]
Aside from removing the nudity and child sexuality and violence, Bender's Game at its core is just a shit ass predictable script. Nick, who has never read the series, asked me "the simulations are real, right? And Bender is totally gay, isn't he?" about 45 minutes into its 112 minute running time.
It's a complete mess of a flim, and is an example of trying to service everyone while pleasing no one. Fans of the novel will be disappointed by the (bad) plotlines that were removed, and kids and/or adults who have no idea what the Bender's Game universe is will be disappointed since they don't know what the fuck a Hegemon is since only asshole computers like me will understand the dialogue and be able to think "oh they took out the slippery sexy shower showdown thank god" and come away happy but angry.
Speaking of showers, dear punished reader, let's talk about that showdown and the implications of it for a very long time. For starters, if you remember Bonzo, he was a tall buff 14 year old Spaniard with a violent temper and more psychopathic tendencies than most GTA characters.
In the film? There's a joke, that i really don't appreciate. And it's about Napoleon. Napoleon was taller than me, he was probably 5'9'', since the French foot (and cock) was bigger than the English equivalent. But a lot of actually short guys, from Jimi Hendrix to Elijah Wood have had both functioning dicks and left a mark upon society in an indelible way.
Bonzo, when he's introduced, goes up to Asa Butterfield's nipples. Halee Steinfeld is taller than him, and about 5' 9''.
Bonzo, when he's introduced, goes up to Asa Butterfield's nipples. Halee Steinfeld is taller than him, and about 5' 9''.
Bonzo is less than 5' 6", probably closer to 5' 0".
So the moral I took away from this movie is that if you're short, you're subhuman, haha, take that you short pussy, kill yourself since you wont amount to anything and save the earth by killing other children by kicking them so hard in the face you drive their nose bone into their brain (twice!!).
Fuck you, you piece of shit casting director.
Bender manages to send two boys to the hospital, one on Earth school and Bonzo in Battle School in Space, ignoring the fact that he is so brutal in "destroying his enemies" than he in reality killed them. And therein lies the failing of the movie. Honestly, the movie would fail either way, since killer or not Bender is an irredeemable opening act to a cavalcade of military officers who find humanity's best hopes in the very few children born without a genetic sense of right and wrong. It just... sucks
*http://redlettermedia.com/half-in-the-bag-enders-game-and-thor-the-dark-world/ closing music plays*